TEAM HERALDteamherald@herald-goa.comPANJIM: The State Information Commissioner has passed an order directing the Office of Chief Electrical Engineer, Electricity Department, Vidyut Bhavan, Panaji to pay a sum of Rs.5000 to Vernon Fonseca for furnishing misleading information under the Right to Information Act, and as a compensation for causing mental and physical harassment for making him repeatedly visit the office in search of the information. “The Appellant… suffered detriment on account of failure to provide correct information. The Appellant through his Power of Attorney holder had to come many a times to the Commission with the hope that correct information would be furnished. This naturally caused mental and physical harassment to the Appellant. Harassment of an information seeker by public authorities is not permissible under RTI. Besides, it is socially abhorring. In this factual scenario instead of going for penal provision, this Commission is considering compensating the Appellant for the loss and detriment suffered by him in having to pursue the matter. Secondly this approach will have a telling effect as it may drastically improve work culture and also change the outlook,” the Information Commissioner M S Keny said in his order. The appellant had sought certified copies of memoranda received by Office of Chief Electrical Engineer from the Office of Chief Minister of Goa, and the office of President of India, and certified copies of reports sent to these offices as per letter dated 20.04.2010.”By his reply dated 22.11.2010, Vincent Fernandes, Executive Engineer (TNG) & S.P.I.O., CEE’s Office, informed the Appellant that report is not received from the Executive Engineer, Elec. Div. VI Mapusa till date as such no report is sent to higher authority. The applicant then opted for an appeal and the First appellate authority (FAA) observed that PIO should collect the information from other concerned PIOs of same Department and furnish to the applicant. However at this stage the PIO furnished wrong information. “I have perused the information furnished. The information sought is the certified copies of the reports sent to ‘these offices” i.e. Office of Hon. Chief Minister and Hon. President. What is given in 8 pages is altogether different,” the CIC noted in his order. “In any case what information furnished is not what was sought by the Appellant and, therefore, it is misleading. The explanation given by PIO is unconvincing. I am of the opinion that the actions of PIOs amount to furnishing misleading information,” the CIC said further while passing the order. The compensation is to be paid to the Appellant directly within 30 days from the receipt of the SIC’s Order.
Originally posted here: Power dept fined for providing wrong info
sending...
